The more I think about Alfonso Cuarón’s “Gravity”, the more
I see it as a mixed bag. On the one hand, it’s a visual experience immersing
the audience in space in a way unlike anything I’ve ever seen before. On the
other hand, I think it falls short of greatness by adhering to crowd-pleasing
elements that distract from the tone and weight of the premise and story.
Sandra Bullock stars as Ryan Stone, a
doctor-turned-astronaut who, while on a spacewalk to set up a deep-space
scanning program she invented, gets stranded when debris destroys the ship,
leaving her and the commanding officer Matthew Kowalski (George Clooney) to
struggle for survival and a way home against all odds.
Where “Gravity” succeeds is in creating an experience. Never
have I felt as close to being in space as I did here. The attention to detail
with movement, sound, and visuals is phenomenal. Whether it be the way Ryan
enters a room in a space station upside down, the lack of sound whenever she
and Kowalski are in space, or the glow of the sunrise creeping on the earth,
the movie creates this environment realistically.
This is one of those movies I’m going to have to see the
behind the scenes features for; some scenes just made me stroke my chin
wondering, “I wonder how they achieved this effect,” or “Think of all the
storyboarding this must have taken to plan!” There’s a soothing scene where
Ryan takes a breather in the space station, floating in the middle of the
airlock for a few minutes. Her movement is so smooth; it makes you believe
she’s really floating in zero gravity. Of course, I don’t know for sure if the
filmmakers shot that scene in a zero gravity simulator of some kind, but the
effect works so well, it makes me want to know how it was done. Did she stay
still and the room moves around her? Were there wires involved, and if so, how
was the wirework executed in order to simulate the movement? Scenes like this
reveal the filmmakers’ creativity and dedication to the environment, it makes
me admire all the work that went into it.
One of the points people have brought up with this movie is
its use of 3D. I think the main problem with 3D is that when using it the old
way, for shock and pop-up effects, it looks hokey and gimmicky. When using it
the new way, to increase depth, the actors end up looking like paper puppets.
3D is intended to break the boundaries of reality and fiction. The line doesn’t
end at the screen; the audience can become enveloped in the story with this
illusion. This is where “Gravity” gets it right. The 3D is used to stretch the
limitations of space, expressing its infinite nature. The IMAX screen is an
advantage here because 3D glasses tend to limit the scope of vision. IMAX
usually gets the audience to sit farther back to see everything, so the 3D can
use depth without sacrificing the audience’s vision. Overall, the effect helps
the visuals; I’d recommend spending the extra money.
So what are my problems with “Gravity”? I think my main
issue is tone. At some points, “Gravity” seems like an art film; the importance
is placed on experience and mood rather than the narrative. However, there are
enough comic relief and pop-out 3D effects to make it more palatable for the
Hollywood crowd. The first couple times, these kinds of choices don’t distract
too much from the story, but after the 3rd time Ryan nearly misses
the spacecraft while being dragged into space, the effect wears thin and it
gets irritating. George Clooney can be a bit much playing Kowalski; his
inability to be fazed is an interesting quality, but decreases the value of the
heavy stakes at hand. Most of the comic relief is attributed to him and save
for a couple scenes, his jokes fall flat. Whenever the movie tries to be more
like an action film, it pulls away from the experience and it ends up bringing
the movie down a notch.
Despite its faults, “Gravity” is a visual masterpiece, using
its attention to detail and its effects to create the most realistic depiction
of space I’ve seen. The visuals are a showstopper, but balance well to serve
the story, which enthralls and weaves tension in a story of trying to survive
at all costs. I definitely recommend it, especially in IMAX 3D. Take a view and
let your perception play around. I’m the Man without a Plan, thanks for
reading, and join me next time for another movie review.
"Gravity" trailer: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OiTiKOy59o4